It’s a Crisis of Infinite Movie Universes

Theorycrafting the Next DC Universe

I am an unabashed DC Comics fan. I have loved the characters since I was a kid, picking up the 1986 Man of Steel comic reboot, and digging through copies of Batman, Superman, Jimmy Olsen, and more. I had friends that were deeply into Marvel, collecting all their comics, and while I won’t deny there were some pretty cool ideas over there – Days of Future Past is a legitimated fantastic scenario from a writing perspective – their books never hooked me the way DC’s did. When I got into collecting comics, I collected DC. Those were the heroes and stories I cared about.

As a child of the 1980s the biggest heroes on screen that we had were DC’s. There was the Superman franchise, the Batman movies directed by Tim Burton, as well as the classic Batman and Wonder Woman television series. Each of these sparked a different kind of love in the generation, especially because you could have the movies and shows all playing on broadcast television and basic cable, never leaving you without a way to see a DC hero any day of the week. It was great, and it was a presence that Marvel couldn’t match at the time.

Roles are reversed for the companies, though. Marvel is the ever-present force now, powered by their Marvel Cinematic UniverseWhen it first began in 2008 with a little film called Iron Man no one suspected the empire that would follow. Superhero movies in the past, especially those not featuring either Batman or Superman, were usually terrible. And yet, Iron Man would lead to a long series of successful films, launching the most successful cinema brand in history: the Marvel Cinematic Universe., and while DC has had some successes, such as The Batman, they do not have the same kind of cultural force among general audiences that Marvel does. Which is shocking since they own three of the four most famous characters in the comic world (SupermanThe first big superhero from DC Comics, Superman has survived any number of pretenders to the throne, besting not only other comic titans but even Wolrd War II to remain one of only three comics to continue publishing since the 1940s., BatmanOne of the longest running, consistently in-print superheroes ever (matched only by Superman and Wonder Woman), Batman has been a force in entertainment for nearly as long as there's been an entertainment industry. It only makes sense, then that he is also the most regularly adapted, and consistently successful, superhero to grace the Silver Screen., and Wonder WomanLong considered the third pillar of the DC Comics "Trinity", Wonder Woman was one of the first female superheroes ever created. Running for as long as Batman or Superman (and without breaks despite a comic downturn in the 60s that killed superhero comics for about a decade), Wondie has the honor to be one of the longest serving, and most prolific, superheroes ever., with Marvel having SpidermanSure, DC Comics has Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman, but among the most popular superheroes stands a guy from Marvel Comics, a younger hero dressed in red and blue who shoots webs and sticks to walls. Introduced in the 1960s, Spider-Man has been a constant presence in comics and more, featured in movies regularly since his big screen debut in 2002.). You would think that, because of that, DC should easily be able to compete with Marvel on the big screen, but time and again DC (and Warner Bros., their parent company, and now Skydance, their current parent-parent company) has managed to fuck that up.

The first attempt at making a cinematic universe was with 2011’s Green Lantern film, a movie that was both critically unloved and a financial disaster. It was meant to be the launchpad for a new DC cinematic universe to compete with the MCU, but it’s utter failure at the Box Office meant that DC quietly scrapped that plan and acted like it was never meant to be anything more than a one off (Universal, of note, did the same thing with their first attempt at a Dark Universe when Dracula Untold failed to win hearts at the Box Office, and they quietly set it aside and pretended it didn’t exist). So DC had to try again.

That attempt came two years later with Zack SnyderOften reviled for the bombastic and idiotic content of his films, there is no question that what Snyder's movies lack in substance they (at least try to) balance out with flash and style, making him one of Hollywood's top directors... sadly.’s Man of Steel, the 2013 film produced by Christopher NolanMade famous when his second film, Memento, became an art-house hit, Nolan became a household name with his Dark Knight trilogy, quickly becoming one of Hollywoods biggest directors. and written by David S. Goyer. Nolan, notably, had directed the whole of The Dark Knight trilogy, a cultural and Box Office success that gave DC the kind of clout to take Marvel on at the Box Office. But Nolan had no interest is tying his Batman films into a larger cinematic universe, so DC had to reset and restart despite having those films right there, with audiences in love with them, so when Man of Steel did pretty well at the Box Office, DC decided that was the film they’d build their cinematic universe off of.

This was their first mistake as Snyder’s vision for DC’s heroes wasn’t really aligned with the actual characters themselves as depicted across eighty years of comic history. But in Zack they trusted, and they gave him the keys to the kingdom so he could fast-track their cinematic universe. First was Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, a movie that audiences generally seemed to hate even though it made over $800 Mil at the Box Office. But most assume that if the film had actually been good, it could have easily made over $1 Bil because it had both Superman and Batman. That should be a license to print money.

Because of that, for Zack’s third film, Justice League, the studio meddled more, pushing him to make something lighter, more appealing to general audiences. And then, when Zack had to step away for personal reasons (due to the death of his daughter), WB brought in a ringer, Joss WhedonOnce considered a great Hollywood writer/director who also had the "feminist" bona fides, in recent years Whedon's star has faded as reports of his on-set behavior has tainted his entire catalog of hits., to fix the film. He failed to do so, and Justice League ended up becoming a giant disaster that left WB holding the bag. They had a cinematic universe no one liked but they had to keep pushing forward because it felt like they had no other options.

So from Aquaman (which was a the only DC Extended UniverseStarted as DC Comics' answer to the MCU, the early films in the franchise stumbled out of the gates, often mired in grim-dark storytelling and the rushed need to get this franchise started. Eventually, though, the films began to even out, becoming better as they went along. Still, this franchise has a long way to go before it's true completion for Marvel's universe. film to cross $1 Bil) through Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom five years later, DC released a host of films in their loosely connected, totally irrelevant cinematic universe, acting like Marvel’s dopey younger brother than could never get their shit together. And after the Aquaman sequel the DCEU was mercy-killed so that James Gunn and Peter Safran could step in to soft reboot the universe, starting with Creature Commandos on the small screen and Superman on the big screen.

As we covered last week, it’s both a tragedy that this second (and a bit) iteration of DC’s cinematic universe, the DCU, has already hit a stumbling block. With Gunn and Safran leaving after the release of Man of Tomorrow and The Batman: Part II, we are likely to get some kind of soft reboot for the universe again. Whatever Gunn’s plans were for the universe, those are certainly scrapped, and it’s still up in the air if Man of Tomorrow even comes out the way Gunn intended or if the higher ups at Skydance meddle with it, too. And from there, who knows? Maybe David Corensweat and the rest of the Superman cast stick around for the future cinematic universe, maybe they don’t. We’ll know nothing until concrete plans are put in place, and those won’t happen for another year or two at least. But what we can be sure of is that at some point we’ll have a very different cinematic universe from what was shaping up even earlier this year, and that’s all because DC simply can’t help but reboot itself over and over again.

So what can the studio do? If it has to reboot in some form just so it can both attract audiences and make money for the shareholders, what is the best path forward? Well, the simple solution is to keep the parts of the current DCU that work, and that aren’t so tied to James Gunn that they can’t go on without him (we won’t see more Creature Commandos or Peacemaker after this, that’s all but certain). Arguably what that would mean is basically that Corensweat’s Clark Kent / Superman, Rachel Brosnahan's Lois Lane, and maybe a few other characters that aren’t toys the new producers want to play with will all carry on. Hawkgirl and Mr. Terrific will probably fade out after Man of Tomorrow because while those are characters many DC fans like, they’re deep-cut characters that general audiences don’t care that much about. Maybe Nathan Fillion's Guy Gardner / Green Lantern sticks around, maybe not, but I think only Superman and maybe Lois are important enough to keep. The rest could be scrapped.

Up until Pattinson was cast as James Bond I would have said that DC could probably throw enough money at him to keep him around as Batman for their cinematic universe. Now, though, I have my doubts. More likely I think The Batman: Part II will get released, and then DC will announce a new Batman, in a new film, to crossover with Corensweat’s Superman. In the meantime, characters like Wonder Woman and The FlashStruck by lightning while working in his lab, Barry Allen became a speedster known as The Flash, launching an entire set of super-fast superheroes. will get launched, and we’ll either get a Green Lantern film starring Guy Gardner and Aaron Pierre’s John Stewart / Green Lantern, or those characters will get rebooted as well in their own film. People liked Kyle Chandler’s Hal Jordan / Green Lantern. Maybe they can throw enough money to bring him back and then handwave away his death at the end of Lanterns.

It is clear, though, that Skydance wants their cinematic universe and they want it now. Much like with the DCEU, where WB couldn’t sit still and build the universe slowly, instead rushing to get to a Justice League film as soon as possible, Skydance is doing the same thing. If I had to guess on a timeline:

  • Man of Steel in 2027
  • Green Lantern in late 2028
  • Wonder Woman in 2029
  • The Flash in 2029
  • A new, rebooted Batman in 2030
  • Maybe a third Superman in 2030
  • And then Justice League in 2031

That’s a timeline that makes sense, and even with four years it still feels rushed. But it at least builds on the ground work Gunn put in (especially if, as the rumors say, Wonder Woman shows up in Man of Tomorrow and Skydance keeps that actress around to play the character moving forward). It’s at least decently paced and uses some of the characters already introduced by Gunn as a springboard for future films. It’s not a great plan since the artistic and authorial voice for the characters will change under new management, but it certainly sounds better than a complete reboot.

That’s assuming Skydance doesn’t throw the baby out with the bathwater and try to do a Justice League movie two years after Man of Tomorrow comes out. But that would be stupid, right? Who would make a giant crossover film the second movie in their cinematic universe? Oh, right… DC did that. Well… let’s hope they don’t do it again.

As a DC fan I’m tired. I won’t deny that. I want to just watch the films that come from DC and enjoy them. I love these characters and I want to see them succeed. But for 13 years now DC (and WB, and now Skydance) have been flailing and it doesn’t seem like that’s going to change any time soon. I want to love these characters on the big screen like I do when I read them on the comic page. My gut, though, says it’s going to be a long time before that really happens again.